Money: Difference between revisions

From Tolkien Gateway
No edit summary
No edit summary
Line 9: Line 9:


==Notes==
==Notes==
In ''[[The Complete Guide to Middle-earth]]'' by [[Robert Foster]], the entry for "Money" on page 344 makes it a point to say that "contrary to the claims of some, there are references to money in ''The Lord of the Rings''". Apparently, in the early "deplorable cultus" days of Tolkien fandom, there were some accusations that "money" (coin money used as actual "currency") did not exist in Middle-earth.  Certain anti-capitalist elements championed the story for promoting such an agenda, while pro-capitalist forces criticized the books on this point. This is similar to (and partially related to) how certain critics believed that Tolkien's rustic utopia of The Shire was espousing a specifically "Luddite" agenda.
In ''[[The Complete Guide to Middle-earth]]'' by [[Robert Foster]], the entry for "Money" on page 344 makes it a point to say  
In reality, coin currency is actually present within the story, its use is simply not highlighted, particularly due to the rustic society of the Shire-Hobbits which the narrative centers around.  Similar to Medieval currency, coinage probably varied widely from region to region, but was still considered exchangeable.  Tolkien did not give more specific information on the kinds of coin money found in Middle-earth, but as he infamously complained, botanists are upset that he did not give a full categorization of all planets in Middle-earth, and geologists are also upset that he did not give a complete area by area survey of the mountains.
 
{{quote|'''contrary to the claims of some''', there are references to money in ''The Lord of the Rings''|The Complete Guide to Middle-earth'' - "Money"}}  
 
The above phrase suggests that (in the early days of [[Tolkien fandom]]) there was some belief that coin money used as actual "currency" did not exist in Middle-earth; references to money are scarce, not highlighted and obviously forgettable among the narrative.
 
It was and partially related to how certain critics believed that Tolkien's rustic utopia of The Shire was espousing a specifically "Luddite" agenda.{{fact}}


==See Also==
==See Also==

Revision as of 07:11, 17 July 2009

"I shan't call it the end, till we've cleared up the mess." — Sam
This article or section needs to be cleaned up to conform to a higher standard of article quality.
"Who told you, and who sent you?" — Gandalf
This article or section needs more/new/more-detailed sources to conform to a higher standard and to provide proof for claims made.

Money, specifically minted coin money, was used in Middle-earth through the Third Age.

History

Money is chiefly mentioned in relation to the trading town of Bree. At the end of the Third Age, a pony was considered to be worth about four silver pennies. The well-to-do owner of the Prancing Pony, Barliman Butterbur, considered a loss of 30 silver pennies to be a considerable blow. A gold piece was regarded as a particularly extravagant reward for good news.

Azog threw a money purse at Nár containing "few coins of little worth" (which the Dwarves later stuffed in the mouth of Azog's decapitated head after his defeat).

Much of the gold and silver wealth of Dwarf-horde of Smaug, appears to have been minted. Bilbo Baggins took home two chests from the horde, one containing gold coins and the other silver coins, and as a result (in addition to his family's pre-existing wealth) lived very comfortably for the next 50 years and was considered quite rich. In addition to the Hobbits of Bree, the Hobbits of the Shire apparently dealt in coin money as well, otherwise they might not have been so eager to search Bag End after Bilbo left, looking for secret treasure rooms.

Notes

In The Complete Guide to Middle-earth by Robert Foster, the entry for "Money" on page 344 makes it a point to say

"contrary to the claims of some, there are references to money in The Lord of the Rings'"
― The Complete Guide to Middle-earth - "Money"

The above phrase suggests that (in the early days of Tolkien fandom) there was some belief that coin money used as actual "currency" did not exist in Middle-earth; references to money are scarce, not highlighted and obviously forgettable among the narrative.

It was and partially related to how certain critics believed that Tolkien's rustic utopia of The Shire was espousing a specifically "Luddite" agenda.[source?]

See Also

References