Tolkien Gateway

Lisa Star

(Difference between revisions)
(Added bibliography)
 
Line 1: Line 1:
 
'''Lisa Star''' edited the journal ''[[Tyalië Tyelelliéva]]'' until [[2001]]. She also used to moderate the Elvish Linguistics mailing list.
 
'''Lisa Star''' edited the journal ''[[Tyalië Tyelelliéva]]'' until [[2001]]. She also used to moderate the Elvish Linguistics mailing list.
  
Star had criticised the "[[Elfconners]]" ([[Arden Smith]], [[Carl Hostetter]], [[Patrick Wynne]], [[Christopher Gilson]]) for their publishing methods. On [[28 October]] [[1996]] she posted in [[Tolklang]] her objections and requested a rapid publication of the original material.<ref>{{webcite|author=Lisa Star|articleurl=http://tolk:lang@tolklang.quettar.org/messages/Vol20/20.89|articlename=Failure of Elfconners|dated=28 October, 1996|website=The Tolkien Language List}}</ref> She would later mention in her website, "There is no love lost between Carl Hostetter and me".<ref>{{webcite|author=Lisa Star|articleurl=http://www.reocities.com/Athens/Parthenon/9902/unpub.html|articlename=A List of Tolkien's Unpublished and Slightly Published Manuscripts|dated=August 2002|website=Welcome to Tyalie Tyelellieva}}</ref>
+
Star had criticised the "Elfconners" ([[Arden Smith]], [[Carl Hostetter]], [[Patrick Wynne]], [[Christopher Gilson]]) for their publishing methods. On [[28 October]] [[1996]] she posted in [[Tolklang]] her objections and requested a rapid publication of the original material.<ref>{{webcite|author=Lisa Star|articleurl=http://tolk:lang@tolklang.quettar.org/messages/Vol20/20.89|articlename=Failure of Elfconners|dated=28 October, 1996|website=The Tolkien Language List}}</ref> She would later mention in her website, "There is no love lost between Carl Hostetter and me".<ref>{{webcite|author=Lisa Star|articleurl=http://www.reocities.com/Athens/Parthenon/9902/unpub.html|articlename=A List of Tolkien's Unpublished and Slightly Published Manuscripts|dated=August 2002|website=Welcome to Tyalie Tyelellieva}}</ref>
  
 
The information she provided has sometimes been criticised as inaccurate or imprecise,<ref>"''Unfortunately, Lisa's linguistic informations often are very imprecise. P. e. she refers to a supposed usage of „Rohirian“ in [[The Peoples of Middle-earth|PM]] p. 55 that does not exist; indeed the word does not occur anywhere in that book at all.''" ([[Andreas Moehn]][http://lalaith.vpsurf.de/Tolkien/How_to_speak_Rohirric.html])</ref> such as the reference to the supposed language "Mørk" by [[Tolkien]].<ref>{{webcite|author=[[Patrick Wynne]] (as Pa2trick)|articleurl=http://cavscrip.wordpress.com/category/the-baleful-eye/sophistry/starism/|articlename=Mørk calling Orsøn, come in Orsøn …|dated=February 22, 2006|website=Caveat Scriptor}}</ref>
 
The information she provided has sometimes been criticised as inaccurate or imprecise,<ref>"''Unfortunately, Lisa's linguistic informations often are very imprecise. P. e. she refers to a supposed usage of „Rohirian“ in [[The Peoples of Middle-earth|PM]] p. 55 that does not exist; indeed the word does not occur anywhere in that book at all.''" ([[Andreas Moehn]][http://lalaith.vpsurf.de/Tolkien/How_to_speak_Rohirric.html])</ref> such as the reference to the supposed language "Mørk" by [[Tolkien]].<ref>{{webcite|author=[[Patrick Wynne]] (as Pa2trick)|articleurl=http://cavscrip.wordpress.com/category/the-baleful-eye/sophistry/starism/|articlename=Mørk calling Orsøn, come in Orsøn …|dated=February 22, 2006|website=Caveat Scriptor}}</ref>

Latest revision as of 16:04, 25 September 2020

Lisa Star edited the journal Tyalië Tyelelliéva until 2001. She also used to moderate the Elvish Linguistics mailing list.

Star had criticised the "Elfconners" (Arden Smith, Carl Hostetter, Patrick Wynne, Christopher Gilson) for their publishing methods. On 28 October 1996 she posted in Tolklang her objections and requested a rapid publication of the original material.[1] She would later mention in her website, "There is no love lost between Carl Hostetter and me".[2]

The information she provided has sometimes been criticised as inaccurate or imprecise,[3] such as the reference to the supposed language "Mørk" by Tolkien.[4]

As of 2008 Star apparently has withdrawn from the Tolkien scene and nobody seemed to be able to contact her.[5] Her official website received a final update in March 2009 before eventually disappearing because of Geocities shutting down.[6]

[edit] Bibliography

[edit] Articles

References

  1. Lisa Star, "Failure of Elfconners" dated 28 October 1996, The Tolkien Language List (accessed 25 November 2020)
  2. Lisa Star, "A List of Tolkien's Unpublished and Slightly Published Manuscripts" dated 1 August 2002, Welcome to Tyalie Tyelellieva (accessed 25 November 2020)
  3. "Unfortunately, Lisa's linguistic informations often are very imprecise. P. e. she refers to a supposed usage of „Rohirian“ in PM p. 55 that does not exist; indeed the word does not occur anywhere in that book at all." (Andreas Moehn[1])
  4. Patrick Wynne (as Pa2trick), "Mørk calling Orsøn, come in Orsøn …" dated 22 February 2006, Caveat Scriptor (accessed 25 November 2020)
  5. Matthew "Tyrhael" Dinse, Message 34824, Elfling
  6. Archive of the final snapshot of her Geocities site